Orkney Islands Council has completed its investigation into alternative governance models, concluding that the current system does not adequately meet the needs of the island community. The council’s review, initiated in 2023, explored options such as greater autonomy within the UK, potential ties with Norway, or adopting a status similar to that of crown dependencies like Jersey and Guernsey. The aim was to address longstanding concerns over funding disparities and policy support.
Council leader James Stockan has been a vocal advocate for exploring these alternatives, citing historical ties to Norway and perceived inequities in resource allocation compared to other Scottish regions. He emphasized that the investigation was not about severing ties with the UK but about finding a governance structure that better serves Orkney’s unique needs.
The investigation involved consultations with legal and constitutional experts, as well as discussions with stakeholders across Orkney. The findings highlighted that while there is interest in exploring different governance models, significant legal and logistical challenges would need to be addressed. Additionally, any substantial change would require extensive consultations and likely legislative action at both the Scottish and UK levels.
In light of these complexities, the council has decided to focus on enhancing its current governance framework. This includes advocating for more equitable funding from both the Scottish and UK governments and seeking greater devolved powers to make decisions that directly impact the island community.
While the exploration of alternative governance models has concluded, the conversation about Orkney’s future remains open. The council has committed to ongoing dialogue with residents and governments to ensure that Orkney’s unique needs are met within the existing constitutional framework.
This development marks a significant moment in Orkney’s political landscape, reflecting a proactive approach to governance and a commitment to securing a sustainable and prosperous future for the islands.
